Buyer guide
Cold email getting no replies?Find the cause in this order
Delivery first, then the list, then the message, then the ask. Most campaigns fail on the first two, and no rewrite fixes those.
First: is it really silence?
Smartlead's 2026 data, more than 850 million emails: the median campaign gets replies from 0.74% of the people it writes to, the top tenth from 2.63% or more.
| People written to | Replies to expect at the median |
|---|---|
| 100 | about 0.7 |
| 300 | about 2.2 |
| 1,000 | about 7.4 |
Source: Smartlead, The State of Cold Email 2026: reply rate per contact (median; January to June 2026, more than 850 million emails). Per contact, not per email: a rate per email sent looks higher.
The causes, in the order to check them
1. The emails are not arriving
- Your domain fails SPF, DKIM or DMARC. Check all three, free.
- The domain or the sending IP is on a blacklist. Blacklist check.
- A new domain or mailbox sends at full volume before it has warmed up.
- Too many emails a day from one mailbox: keep each to a few dozen and add mailboxes instead.
- Links, images and open-tracking pixels in a first email push it toward spam.
2. The wrong people
- The list is broad: everyone with a title, not companies with a reason to buy now. How to narrow it.
- The person does not own the problem: too senior, or in the wrong team.
- Old or unverified addresses bounce and hurt the mailbox. Check the list.
3. The message
- It is about you, not about them: features and a company history.
- It is long. A first email that does not fit on a phone screen rarely gets read.
- It could go to anyone: nothing in it shows you looked at their company.
- The subject line reads like a newsletter or a pitch. Grade it · check for spam words.
4. The ask
- It asks for 30 minutes from a stranger. A yes-or-no question is easier to answer.
- Several links and several asks: give one.
- No follow-ups, or the same email sent again instead of something new.
What the numbers tell you
| What you see | Most likely |
|---|---|
| Bounces above a few percent | An old or unverified list |
| Good replies at first, then nothing | Spam placement: volume rose too fast, or a blacklist |
| Replies, but all "not interested" or "wrong person" | The list: wrong companies or wrong titles |
| Opens tracked but no replies | The message or the ask; and open tracking is unreliable, so do not trust it alone |
| Nothing at all after a few hundred contacts | Delivery. Check it before you rewrite anything |
Get a second pair of eyes
Paste an email and get a line-by-line review, free and with no sign-up.
Questions
What is a good cold email reply rate?
How many emails before I know a campaign does not work?
How do I know if my emails land in spam?
Do follow-ups help?
Rather pay only for results?
Outlevo sends from mailboxes it sets up and warms, writes each email from the company's own pages and charges per held meeting: Founder $300, Mid-market $450 and Enterprise $750 per held meeting.